Discussion forum on Fresco painting technique and workshop, visual and performing arts, gallery and museum exhibitions, advice on art marketing from professional art agent, fresco documentary, artist promotion,
 


TrueFresco.com | Technique | Image Gallery | Fresco School | Art Commissions | Art Gazette | Art Events | Shop


Dear guest! You must login to see/use new forum features. If you are a new user, please register.


Subject: "Copyright of a Public Art - Who owns it?"     Previous Topic | Next Topic
Printer-friendly copy     Email this topic to a friend    
Conferences Fresco Painting Public Art Topic #2
Reading Topic #2
Iliamoderator
Charter Member
339 posts, Rate this user
14-Aug-02, 10:45 AM (PST)
Click to EMail Ilia Click to send private message to Ilia Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list Click to visit 's homepage Click to send message via AOL IM  
"Copyright of a Public Art - Who owns it?"
 
> Dear all,
>
> I have a problem. When someone takes a photograph of a public
> monument new or old, then creates a brochure or publication. Has the
> photographer or the person who commissioned the photogragher the
> right to reproduce this picture or do they have to seek permission
> from the local state council or artist to reproduce the photograph of
> the public monument.
> Once a Public monument is created and in public view who owns the
> copyright?
> Or can anyone make gain or profit what is essentially public?

Copyright in general is a civil , not a criminal issue. So, regardless of
your rights to the ownership of the intellectual property contained in your
sculpture, you must prosecute your rights establish them] in the civil court system.

Calling 911 does not connect to the Copyright Police.
<"There's a dead copyright on the landing.">
Hire a lawyer.

Furthermore, if you feel that your intellectual property rights have been
stolen, you must prove your damages - that the entity that photographed your
work stole something of value from you by reproducing your work in a photo.

The counter argument can be made that by publicizing your work, you received
a benefit in exposure - free advertising.

You might have damages if a photograph appeared on a poster for sale that
featured your name prominently and representation of your work]. That is why lawyers make the big bucks- to
construct convincing arguments to get money.

My opinion is that once a work is in the public domain, the only protection
you have is against people actually replicating your sculpture and calling
it their own work. Then, you could only expect to receive their profit from
their action.

In British Columbia, a new, architecturally exciting waterfront convention
centre was built. Their lawyers asserted copyright over every photograph of
the waterfront of Vancouver featuring this structure. It didn't get very
far.

I sympathize with your anger and pain. But the fight to retain control over
intellectual property is a fight best undertaken by rich guys against guys
with lots of dough. For instance, if you are rich, you would do better suing
George Harrison over some lyrics.

Dwight "licensed to be cynical" Atkinson, MAIBC

Canada's Funniest Architect

Architect Atkinson Iconography Studio Incorporated
2243 West 47 Avenue, Vancouver, BC, Canada, V6M 2M8
fax: 604-266-7342 voice: 604-266-7322

_____________________________

I have received this article from the PubArt mail list that I subscribe to and decided to share it with you.

ilia

http://www.FrescoSchool.com


  Alert | IP User Menu | Scratch Pad | Printer-friendly page | Edit | Reply | Reply With Quote | Top
christaki
unregistered user
11-Feb-06, 02:59 PM (PST)
 
1. "RE: Copyright of a Public Art - Who owns it?"
In response to message #0
 
   I'm not sure what to say.Maybe no one ownes it once it;s released to the general public.My website is full of paintings of great masters, but you can not say that i'm violating any laws, do you?
http://www.allartclassic.com


  Alert | IP User Menu | Scratch Pad | Printer-friendly page | Edit | Reply | Reply With Quote | Top
valerielukas
Member since 12-Jun-12
1 posts, Rate this user
12-Jun-12, 03:02 AM (PST)
Click to EMail valerielukas Click to send private message to valerielukas Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list Click to send message via ICQ  
4. "RE: Copyright of a Public Art - Who owns it?"
In response to message #1
 
   According to Stitadhi Rath, you are violating the rules because your are not the creator of the paintings which you have.

granite boca raton


  Alert | IP User Menu | Scratch Pad | Printer-friendly page | Edit | Reply | Reply With Quote | Top
Stitadhi Rath
Member since 2-Aug-10
2 posts, Rate this user
12-Aug-10, 07:53 AM (PST)
Click to EMail Stitadhi%20Rath Click to send private message to Stitadhi%20Rath Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list Click to visit 's homepage  
3. "RE: Copyright of a Public Art - Who owns it?"
In response to message #0
 
   Hi,
Before we discuss copyright licensing, let's just refresh ourselves as to the meaning of the word copyright. Copyright protection is given to the owner of original works they have written, drawn or composed regardless of whether it is published or unpublished. So when you think of copyrighting, you should be thinking of art, music, drama or literary works. Some other intellectual property items will fall under copyrighting protection as well but these are the main types.

Thanks


  Alert | IP User Menu | Scratch Pad | Printer-friendly page | Edit | Reply | Reply With Quote | Top

Conferences | Forums | Topics | Previous Topic | Next Topic
Rate this topicRate this topic

Take Advantage of the Free Shipping!




Cafe al Fresco Entrance Hall - first stop for a "newbe" or browse while "your dinner at our Cafe is being served". Annoincements, Educational resources, feedback, polls. Also includes popular "Bar Stool... Just Art!" Forum. Contemporary Fresco Painting Resource Center discussions. Fresco Technique, Modern & Classic Fresco History, Workshop, Tutorials and comments. Includes Murals & Trompe L'oeil, Architecture & Design topics and "Kids Corner". Fresco Workshop Students (members only) Forum also found here. Voice your opinion on Art and Culture in general or discuss a particular artwork. What is your take on the Art for the Future? Create your own gallery or contribute to our Group Exhibitions. Get your own work reviewed or review other members art. Theatre and else... Music, Cinematograph, Writers Table, The Poets Club, Comedy Central, etc. Support Forums for the TrueFresco.com Art World Community - Free web sites provided by TrueFresco.com Nightlife, Internet, Travel & Leasure and miscellanies topics. Get all of the current posts in a glance!








ART  COMMUNITY CHANNEL  GUIDE

WELCOME Channel

.
News, media headlines, articles, pictures, art promotion, reviews, art critique, reviews, fine and decorative arts resources, discussions, debates, art event calendars, art clubs - all things art organized in content channels by topics of interest.
.

Dynamic, on-the-fly, automated content updates - post your image in our FPAA&ID Image Database/Gallery or post your Article in the Cafe al Fresco Forums and see it distributed throughout our Content Channels. As well as World Media News feeds specific to each channel.

         

FRESCO PAINTING Channel

         

MURAL, TROMPE & FAUX Channel

         

SCULPTURE Channel

         

ART CRITIQUE Channel

         

ART DEBATES Channel

         

ART MARKETING Channel